BA Phot

Blog, Identity and Place 2020-21

Back - Latest

- Jan - Feb - Mar - Apr - May - Jun - Jul - Aug - Sep - Oct - Nov - DecI&P - C&N - EyV2018 - 2019 - 2020

Quotes - I&P milestones — Asg. 1 - Part 1

1st Jul 2020

This blog tracks the activities and progress of my BA in Photography with OCA. It started in 2018 with Expressing your vision, then Context and Narrative and now this.


Printing - Workflow - Referencing - Corona Image Deficit - Why photograph? - Zine

- Jan - Feb - Mar - Apr - May - Jun - Jul - Aug - Sep - Oct - Nov - DecI&P - C&N - EyV2018 - 2019 - 2020

1st July


This is a copy of the 1st July post in the C&N blog.

While awaiting a tutorial on C&N Asg.5, it's time to prepare for I&P. The checklist is:

Eyebrow, July 2020

30th July


Work is well under way on the transfer from C&N to I&P and I have started work on the Preamble. I will probably apply for the course in a few weeks.

I expect to print and bind the C&N zine this week and then try to identify and produce the C&N FinAss submission.

- Jan - Feb - Mar - Apr - May - Jun - Jul - Aug - Sep - Oct - Nov - DecI&P - C&N - EyV2018 - 2019 - 2020

5th August


I have finished the Preamble and Square Mile II and am starting Part 1.

6th August

Olga Karlovac
b: ? Dubrovnik
Site - Ecad

Striking photographs - Olga Karlovac

Given my wish to produce clear representations of what things look like, I wouldn't normally expect to be drawn to such images, but an article in this month's B&W Photography featured Olga Karlovac's new(ish) book, the disarray. Her technique is described as using slow shutter speeds to generate motion blur and photographing in bad weather with rain on her lens. The camera used for the book is a Ricoh GR II (fixed focal length lens approx. 28mm equivalent, no viewfinder).

Daniel Castonguay
b: ? Canada
Site - Monovisions

The effect is impressionistic. It reminds me, in a way, of a photographer I came across while researching self portraits for C&N, Daniel Castonguay.

I cannot see me attempting to make images anything like these, but I would like to try some time. I think I would try the effect in colour at first, perhaps desaturated. I remember being astonished decades ago by a photograph by John Hedgecoe — I had several of his books and will have a hunt. There was one completely out of focus and, I think, taken in Paris without a lens. I always wanted to play with this effect. The closest I have come is a picture in the British Museum for EyV.

Olga Karlovac Olga Karlovac Daniel Castonguay Daniel Castonguay logo ex 2.6
1-2. Olga Karlovac from Disarray
3. Daniel Castonguay, The Runner
4. Daniel Castonguay, The Windows
5. John Hedgecoe
6. Rachid Koraïchi Calligraphic figure, British Museum, from EyV, August 2018
© the artists, their agents or their estates

Pill, S. (2020) Tales of Disarray. Black+White Photography. Issue no. 243, pp.28-35.

11th August

Evaluating photographs

I have gathered together my various jottings on the matter and the cmat instructions for Exc. 1.1 and created a workable approach to apply. We'll see.


Dawoud Bey

From Dawoud Bey (further details here)

I discourage my students from talking about photographing as "shooting" or "capturing" or "taking," because it's really about trying to figure out a way to describe with the camera, to make something. Dawoud Bey, on Photographing People and Communities, p.29

19th August


My reluctance to embrace Harvard Referencing for anything other than assignment submissions has been stated not infrequently (see Nov 2018 and Dec 2019) but the time has come to accept it. I think the final conversion occurred when assembling the C&N zine and the Wordpress sites for C&N and EyV — it would be easier and neater to assemble a single, central set of references and therefore standardisation is essential. I have started retrofitting Harvard to all I&P material and will stick to Harvard thereafter with one exception, references to the course material as, for example I&P p.18 will continue except in assignments. And I'll use ibid. too.

[17Sep] There's a great resource on referencing here from the Limerick Institute of Technology - backup.

21st August


I spent some time today considering alternative courses to I&P — firstly because I have only just realised (or been reminded) that there are alternatives; secondly because I am really interested in trying photgravure and I enjoyed making the C&N zine so much.

I&P is the pure photography course for #3 but there are others - Moving Image 1: Setting the Scene / Moving Image 1: An Introduction to Film Culture / Visual Studies 1: Understanding Visual Culture / Book Design 1: Creative Book Design / Visual Studies 1: Creative Arts Today / Writing 1: Writing Skills / Graphic Design 1: Core Concepts / Visual Skills 1: Visual Dynamics / Printmaking 1: Introduction to Printmaking.

There have been a couple of gravure articles lately that have sparked my interest. Neither are to hand at the moment (one was in B&W Phot, the other I think in the L'Oeil de la Photographie  daily briefing). Part 1 of the Printmaking course is here. Unfortunately you can't get by on photography alone, you need some practical graphical skills so that excludes me. Most importantly, it does no go anywhere near gravure. Here's an interesting post, Photopolymer printing on a budget

The Book Design course (Part 1 here) is superficially attractive but I'm not sure I would get much out of it having already done the zine. I'm happy with what I have learned and ready to tackle the next book.

I might look at some of the others.

29th August

Stained Glass

I blogged during C&N about my front room windows probably being the last thing I would photograph. Here they are on another fine day, 36th August.

Windows Windows Windows
Windows, 26th August

- Jan - Feb - Mar - Apr - May - Jun - Jul - Aug - Sep - Oct - Nov - DecI&P - C&N - EyV2018 - 2019 - 2020


Richard Avedon

[8Sep] Surface, aspirations to photograph beneath, and the possibilities thereof are covered in the I&P Preamble. Dawoud Bey paraphrases Richard Avedon on the matter and here's a direct quote.

My photographs don't go below the surface. They don't go below anything. They're readings of what's on the surface. Avedon in Henry Carroll's Photographers on Photography (2018, p.80)

19th September

The photograph

In August I toyed with definitions of various aspects of photography, see here. Last night I wrote,

a photograph is a copy of what a moment in time somewhere looked like
to the extent that, through processing, it is not, to that extent it is no longer a photograph me

I was aiming to channel Lincoln here, 'Whatever differs from this, to the extent of the difference, is no democracy' (1858). There is scope for getting closer.

[21Sep] This echoes a quote I encountered a few days later in an essay by Michael Mitchell, Verum Factum, in Thirteen essays on photography (1990),

… I want to show the unborn what it once looked like. I want them to see what we once saw and what we thought was significant. Michael Mitchell, Verum Factum, in Thirteen essays on photography (1990),

Canadian Museum of Contemporary Photography (1990) Thirteen essays on photography. Chicago: University of Chicago Press

The full paragraph is worth noting and there are several other goodies from Mitchell I'll put on a page if time allows.
Searching for any other pieces, I note that he died in May this year at 76. Obit

This continued with the thought that the act of ph. consists of subject and treatment. Or perhaps a subject and a series of treatments (taking , processing, display etc.).

And that historically, film has always had two arms reality (documentary and news) and fantasy (the movies).

Stills ph. began with realism and fantasy
realism included portrait, landscape, still life, scientific
fantasy began with tableau (e.g. Cameron) and collage (Rejlander).

or making in Bey's terms


Robert Graham

From Here's Me! or The Subject in The Picture in Thirteen essays on photography (1990) p.4.

The transformation by photography is the metamorphosis of a subject into an object Robert Graham in Here's Me! or The Subject in The Picture, 1990

He goes on to examine how the subject might reclaim or roll back the process of objectification through various types of discourse between the photographer and the photographee.

[spellchecked to here]

Window 22Sep20
Window 22Sep20

22nd Sep

SG Window

This morning, see 29th August.

25th September

I'm just about to apply for the course. Here's an update on a previous post elsewhere.

Summer 20 - 78, 72, 72, 68, 68, 66, 66, 65, 65, 63, 63, 62, 62, 62, 58, 55, 54, 53
Mar 20 - 50, 51, 52, 52, 53, 54, 58, 58, 61, 62, 64
Nov 19 - 42, 48, 53, 54, 54, 55, 67
Jul 19 - 50, 52, 52, 54, 54, 59, 60, 63, 65, 66, 67, 72
Mar 19 - 59, 62, 65, 65, 65

Summer 20 - 74, 70, 66, 60, 56, 55, 50, 0
Mar 20 - 53, 57, 58, 62, 62, 63, 65, 65
Nov 19 - 62, 63, 72, 73
Jul 19 - 0 (!), 46, 48, 51, 58, 62, 63, 63, 64, 65, 66, 70
Mar 19 - 54, 54, 55, 56, 56, 58, 61, 65, 65, 66, 68, 69, 72, 73, 85

Summer 20 - 72, 68, 64, 63, 58, 58, 5850, 47, 0
Mar 20 - 68, 62, 58, 50, 46, 43
Nov 19 - 72, 70, 68, 67, 65, 64, 63, 62, 61, 60, 60, 60, 52
Jul 19 - 64
Mar 19 - 73, 60, 58, 54, 53, 51

25-26th September


While I'm waiting for my application to join the course, let's run through the assignments. Bearing in mind I only have part 1 of the course material at the moment, several of the assignments ask for the application of "what you've just learned", so there's guesswork in here.

1. The non-familiar
Five portraits of unknown local people
I have had no better ideas than charity shops triptych - exterior person on the till, pano of till and surrounds. The backup is similar groups of emporia - pubs, cafes etc. or the same ideas a little further afield. Save tattoo parlours for Asg.3.

2. Vice Versa
Five portraits interior and exterior. Same person or several
Either 5 of Mrs. B or August Sander derived, maybe workers - street cleaner, traffic warden etc.

3. Mirrors and Windows
Either photos of a group you are part of
or a local group you do not yet know.
I'm not in any local groups, so it's the window. I have often thought of offering my services to one or more tatoo parlours - that resembles a commuity.

4. Title?
7-10 pictures using course ideas, combining images and text.
That will have to wait - Part 4 is headed Image and text with sections Captions and titles / Memories and speech / Fictional texts

5. Title?
Part 5 is headed Removing the figure with sections Absence and signs of life and Places and spaces
This will have to wait but it promises the possibility of fewer people in the snaps.

Overall standards
I remain wedded to the idea of sticking with 6x7 and optional 6x14 panoramas. I still like borders.

Nasos Karabelas
b: 1992 Pyrgos, Greece
Instagram - Behance
Hélène Brugnes
Instagram - LensCulture

26th September

The realist∼abstract continuum

Many of the visual art forms manifest a dimension that spans a continuum from realism to abstract. There is a cusp on that continuum that is a sweet spot such as that occupied by Henry Moore in sculpture where some of his figures are evidently derived from the human, but only just so: of his contemporaries, Hepworth is usually at the far end of abstract and Epstein working a rich seam more towards the realist.

These came to mind this morning with the daily post from L'oeil de la photographie showing the work of Nasos Karabelas and Hélène Brugnes.

Nasos Karabelas Nasos Karabelas Nasos Karabelas Nasos Karabelas Hélène Brugnes Hélène Brugnes Hélène Brugnes Hélène Brugnes
Figs. 1-4 Nasos Karabelas
Figs. 5-8 Hélène Brugnes
© the artists

Karabelas, at the beginning of a long paragraph, says,

This series is the attempt to understand the functioning of sensations. To explore the space of emotions and the interaction between the forms of the image and the viewer. Nasos Karabelas

Brugnes says of her series,

The hyperrealistic image of a summer day on a Moroccan beach vanishes into a dreamlike abstraction in which only the idea of movement remains.Hélène Brugnes

The EXIF data for Brugnes' images have not been cleared. Although some of the lens data does not make sense, they were made on a Nikon D7000 and the shutter speeds were 1/10th, 1/15th, 1/15th, 1/8th.

I started writing about surrealism today too.

28th September

Why photograph?

On 16th May last, during C&N, I wrote,

To produce a visual representation of something that merits this attention in such a way as to do the subject justice. All these judgements are necessarily subjective and and the terms deliberately ambiguous. me 15th May 2020

Last night I shortened this to,

To make a visual expression of an interest. me 27th September 2020

I think I still might prefer the May version, although this has the advantage of brevity.

See also my w-i-p page on roles.

29th September

We're off

I paid for the course today.

- Jan - Feb - Mar - Apr - May - Jun - Jul - Aug - Sep - Oct - Nov - DecI&P - C&N - EyV2018 - 2019 - 2020

Lenswork #83

9th October


I am reprocessing Part 1 using the online version and inserting amy new components. It will soon be time to venture out and take some photographs. My new tutor has emailed to arrange an online intro chat on 13th.

I came upon a fellow student yesterday who has a handsome site, a sound approach and even more books than I. I arrived there through his review of the Bill Jay, Lenswork Memorial editionhere's the link to Steve Middlehurst. Steve has reached a good compromise on referencing.

C&N zine

10th October


I have send a copy of the C&N zine to my old tutor.

Having worked through the new version of I&P Part 1 and inserted the new bits into my notes that had been based on the freely available extract, I now need to complete the exercises and the assignment for Part 1. These comprise:
Exc 1.3 - Portraiture typology - I propose to photograph armed police
Exc 1.4 - Archival intervention - raid the family albums
Asg 1 - The non-familiar - photograph High Street charity shops, or alternative vendors in the case on non-cooperation.

Parliament 12Oct20

13th October

Exercise 1.3

To town yesterday for the first course-driven photo-outing since 14th May and the Lidl's checkout security camera for C&N Asg.3 (and even that was really shopping-driven).

The targets were armed police at Downing Street and outside Parliament for some Sander typology. I will try to repeat the exercise at Kings Crustation at some point, but now to Asg.1.


I had my inaugural chat with my new tutor today and we agreed a target date for Asg.1 of 6th December.

Demelza, 16th October

17th October


The assignment is going remarkably well. As I note on the development page, "I am surprised how willing, or even enthusiastic the participants are".

And I joined my first I&P online chat today, organised by Mark and with Peter and Zoe in attendance.

Lorna Blackburn
22nd March 2019

23rd October

Progress and the Virus image deficit

I have written Exc. 1.4 (though it remains too long) and called a halt on Exc. 1.3 which now joins the Crown Jewels as a virus image deficit case, see C&N.

Onward with Asg. 1.


25th October

Jo Spence

We encountered Spence in Part 1 with her method of analysing and evaluating portraits.

I hadn't realised what a fascinationg and entertaining revolutionary character she was. I attended (digitally) a conference on Saturday, Let us now praise famous women and particularly enjoyed Patrizia Di Bello (Birkbeck) on Jo Spence as a writer, organiser & photographer. I believe a podcast will be made available and I will add a link.

I grabbed a few screens during the lecture and will start a Jo Spence page with those.


nn October



- Jan - Feb - Mar - Apr - May - Jun - Jul - Aug - Sep - Oct - Nov - DecI&P - C&N - EyV2018 - 2019 - 2020

(rn) author (year) title [online]. web site. Available from url [Accessed nn January 2020].

n. author, init (year) Title. Location: Publisher.

quote cite


[28Dec19] I have been collecting apposite quotes since starting the web site, but rather apathetically because I did not have a convenient means of storing and referencing them. Here's the original page. This is a new plan - stash them in the blog (which I often have) and list the sources here. I'll add navigation arrows through the entries. As currently conceived, the quotes gathered during each course will remain discrete in that blog - I might organise a way around that.

Richard Avedon - surface
Dawoud Bey - shooting
Erwin Blumenfeld - photography is easy (or is it?).
A.D. Coleman - All photographs are fictions
John Coplans - meaninglessness
Paul Dirac - poetry vs. science
Marcel Duchamp - photography vs. painting
William Fox Talbot - chance and charm
Peter Galassi - Photography is a bastard
Paul Graham - orthodoxy
Robert Graham subject → object
Bill Jay - photography's destination
Matisse - objects and surroundings
me - why photograph?
Steven Pippin - inverse sophistication
Sontag - intention, loosely bound
Sontag - mortality, vulnerability, mutability
Alec Soth - still photography is incompatible with the narrative sequence.
Tom Stoppard - recognising quality
Evelyn Waugh - first or a fourth
Edward Weston - the thing itself
Oscar Wilde - on masks

text cite
Page created 01-Jul-2020 | Page updated 25-Oct-2020